AY Patel’s 14 for 225 in the test at Mum-WS between India and New Zealand was in a losing cause to provide the 37^th occasion of a spin bowler’s ten plus wickets in a test going in vain. All such occasions are tabulated below in the descending order of wickets captured by the bowler.

No	Player	W-Runs	Team	Opp	Ground	Mon/Year
1	AY Patel	14-225	NZl	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 2021
2	H Trumble	12-089	Aus	Eng	The Oval	Aug 1896
3	SK Warne	12-128	Aus	SAF	Sydney	Jan 1994
4	DL Vettori	12-149	NZl	Aus	Auckland	Mar 2000
5	H Trumble	12-173	Aus	Eng	The Oval	Aug 1902
6	KA Maharaj	12-283	SAF	Srl	Col-SSC	Jul 2018
7	JJ Krejza	12-358	Aus	Ind	Nagpur	Nov 2008
8	NGB Cook	11-083	Eng	Pak	Karachi	Mar 1984
9	Saeed Ajmal	11-111	Pak	Win	Providence	May 2011
10	RG Nadkarni	11-122	Ind	Aus	Chennai	Oct 1964
11	Taijul Islam	11-170	Ban	Zim	Sylhet	Nov 2018
12	AL Valentine	11-204	Win	Eng	Manchester	Jun 1950
13	Muralitharan	11-212	Srl	Aus	Galle	Mar 2004
14	DL Underwood	11-215	Eng	Aus	Adelaide	Jan 1975
15	Harbhajan Singh	11-224	Ind	Aus	Bengaluru	Oct 2004
16	BS Chandrasekhar	11-235	Ind	Win	Mumb-BS	Dec 1966
17	RJ Bright	10-111	Aus	Pak	Karachi	Feb 1980
18	Muralitharan	10-115	Srl	Eng	Birmingham	May 2006
19	Maninder Singh	10-126	Ind	Pak	Bengaluru	Mar 1987
20	Ghulam Ahmed	10-130	Ind	Aus	Kolkata	Nov 1956
21	Mushtaq Ahmed	10-143	Pak	NZl	Lahore	Nov 1996
22	Saeed Ajmal	10-146	Pak	SAF	Cape Town	Feb 2013
23	PA Strang	10-158	Zim	NZl	Bulawayo	Sep 2000
24	R Ashwin	10-160	Ind	Srl	Galle	Aug 2015
25	HV Hordern	10-161	Aus	Eng	Sydney	Feb 1912
26	SK Warne	10-162	Aus	Eng	Birmingham	Aug 2005
27	EAS Prasanna	10-174	Ind	Aus	Chennai	Dec 1969
28	D Bishoo	10-174	Win	Pak	Dub-DSC	Oct 2016
29	Iqbal Qasim	10-175	Pak	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 1979
30	DL Vettori	10-184	NZl	Srl	Wellington	Dec 2006
31	BS Bedi	10-194	Ind	Aus	Perth	Dec 1977
32	CV Grimmett	10-201	Aus	Eng	Nottingham	Jun 1930
33	BAW Mendis	10-209	Srl	Ind	Galle	Jul 2008
34	L Embuldeniya	10-210	Srl	Eng	Galle	Jan 2021
35	Saqlain Mushtaq	10-216	Pak	Ind	Delhi	Feb 1999
36	S Shillingford	10-219	Win	Aus	Roseau	Apr 2012
37	SP Gupte	10-223	Ind	Win	Kanpur	Dec 1958

It also provides the third occasion of a New Zealand spin bowler witnessing his ten wicket haul in a losing cause. All such occasions are tabulated below.

No	Player	W-Runs	Team	Opp	Ground	Mon/Year
1	AY Patel	14-225	NZl	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 2021
2	DL Vettori	12-149	NZl	Aus	Auckland	Mar 2000
3	DL Vettori	10-184	NZl	Srl	Wellington	Dec 2006

It also provides the fifth occasion of a spin bowler witnessing his ten wicket haul in a losing cause against India. All such occasions are tabulated below.

No	Player	W-Runs	Team	Opp	Ground	Mon/Year
1	AY Patel	14-225	NZl	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 2021
2	JJ Krejza	12-358	Aus	Ind	Nagpur	Nov 2008
3	Iqbal Qasim	10-175	Pak	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 1979
4	BAW Mendis	10-209	Srl	Ind	Galle	Jul 2008
5	Saqlain Mushtaq	10-216	Pak	Ind	Delhi	Feb 1999

It also provides the fourth occasion of a visiting spin bowler witnessing his ten wicket haul in a losing cause against India on Indian soil. All such occasions are tabulated below.

No	Player	W-Runs	Team	Opp	Ground	Mon/Year
1	AY Patel	14-225	NZl	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 2021
2	JJ Krejza	12-358	Aus	Ind	Nagpur	Nov 2008
3	Iqbal Qasim	10-175	Pak	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 1979
4	Saqlain Mushtaq	10-216	Pak	Ind	Delhi	Feb 1999

It also provides the second occasion of a visiting spin bowler witnessing his ten wicket haul in a losing cause against India at Mum-WS. Both such occasions are tabulated below.

No	Player	W-Runs	Team	Opp	Ground	Mon/Year
1	AY Patel	14-225	NZl	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 2021
2	Iqbal Qasim	10-175	Pak	Ind	Mumbai	Dec 1979